Sir, – As a secondary teacher, the more I digest the public service pay agreement, the more it unravels. Was there any discussion during negotiations on the lack of good faith by the Government in withholding the 1 per cent local bargaining in the previous agreement? It appears they are at it again with the discrepancy over the 2 per cent local bargaining in the proposed new deal.
What “efficiencies” are proposed? I thought productivity deals were in return for real wage increases, not a cost-of-living deal.
Given that inflation is currently more than 4 per cent, why aren’t the wage increases more front loaded, and furthermore predictions of future inflation are very optimistic. The review group is just kicking the can down the road.
I note the unions rushing to endorse the deal. I will await clarification on the above points before I decide how to cast my vote. – Yours, etc,
RM Block
DAVE COSTELLO
ASTI member,
Cúil Aodha,
Co Cork.
Sir, – David McWilliams’ evocative childhood recollection of his family’s “good room” will no doubt ring true with many readers (“How can Ireland afford to be so generous to public sector workers?”, November 14th). However, his insinuation that trade unions somehow hoodwinked a Government preoccupied with impressing the “cosmopolitan, multilingual continentals” unfairly casts their demands as unreasonable.
During the financial crisis, public servants were expected to accept pay cuts in the national interest. Yet now, amid economic growth, even seeking to maintain the real value of their wages seems to invite criticism.
If a worker seeks a pay increase merely to keep pace with inflation, they’re not demanding to become richer. They’re simply asking not to become poorer.
If workers are expected to accept lower standards of living in times of both recession and prosperity, one wonders why they should be so enthusiastic about the supposed privilege of economic growth at all. – Yours, etc,
JONATHAN FARRAR,
Abbeyshrule,
Co Longford.
Sir, – Barry Denham (Letters, November 13th) asks what’s in the public sector pay deal for the taxpayers, citing hospital waiting lists as an example. Having recently undergone serious and successful surgery at a Dublin hospital involving a 10-day stay, may I offer my own perspective.
From my experience I could not fault the diligence, professionalism, skill and sheer hard work of the hospital staff, from surgeons through doctors, nurses, catering staff and many others I encountered.
As for hospital waiting lists, I would doubt very much that hospital staff would have it within their power to intervene in that issue. I am not qualified to comment on other branches of the public service, but in my humble opinion whatever pay increase the health sector has achieved it is still not enough. – Yours, etc,
Y THOMAS NAGHTEN,
Maynooth,
Co Kildare.








