The Irish Times view on Microsoft and air traffic outages: a fragile system

Both incidents raise questions about whether those who depend on these systems are properly prepared

Travelers wait for delayed flights at San Francisco International Airport during a ground stop in San Francisco on Friday, Nov. 13, 2026. The Federal Aviation Administration announced a rare nationwide ground stop in the afternoon, halting nearly all departures and stranding thousands of passengers in what appeared to be a major outage affecting its air traffic control system. Photo: Erin Schaff/The New York Times
Travelers wait for delayed flights at San Francisco International Airport during a ground stop in San Francisco on Friday, Nov. 13, 2026. The Federal Aviation Administration announced a rare nationwide ground stop in the afternoon, halting nearly all departures and stranding thousands of passengers in what appeared to be a major outage affecting its air traffic control system. Photo: Erin Schaff/The New York Times

Most of the governance, commerce and social interaction conducted in the modern world is now reliant on an extraordinarily intricate web of physical hardware, complex software and proprietary cloud services controlled by a handful of companies. That alone should raise concerns about the security and stability of the systems on which so much of daily life now depends.

Two dramatic outages in recent days have exposed the fragility of that web. Thankfully, neither the Microsoft incident, in which a faulty network capacity upgrade saw millions of Outlook, Teams and OneDrive users inconvenienced, nor the fault in the US air traffic control network caused by a router upgrade in Arkansas, which grounded thousands of flights, appears to have led to loss of life.

But the consequences were serious. Here, the Health Service Executive found its emails were not being delivered. In Britain, health staff resorted to paper records, while the German government warned of a very big impact on its economy.

The US Federal Aviation Administration halted all departing flights for about four hours on Friday, the longest such shutdown since the September 11th attacks. More than 6,600 flights were cancelled and thousands more delayed, with the disruption running through the weekend.

Both outages raise questions about whether those who depend on these systems are properly prepared, and whether fallback arrangements are adequate. With rising concern that developments in artificial intelligence make these systems more vulnerable than ever to attack and disruption, it is clear that risk assessments and mitigation measures require more sustained attention from governments and companies alike.

The US flight grounding has prompted a spate of finger-pointing between Republicans and Democrats over who is to blame for under-investment in air traffic control. That feeds into two related political critiques. The first is of the long-standing failure of the federal government to invest adequately in public infrastructure. The second relates to the fear that the Trump administration’s vocal contempt for many of those who operate the country’s public services has led to a damaging loss of expertise and experience.

Alongside concerns about American political stability, there are real worries, too, particularly in Europe, about over-reliance on the powerful US companies that control the world’s cloud computing.

Even if political winds in the US show signs of shifting, this dependence has correctly been identified as a strategic weakness which needs to be addressed. Europe has found itself eclipsed by the US in the new digital technologies of the 21st century. Redressing the balance will not be easy, but it is nonetheless an imperative.