Sir, – I was puzzled by Jack Power’s description (“Europe’s ability to fund Ukraine may be limited”, World News, November 12th) of the €6 billion figure for Ireland’s exposure under its guarantee of the €90 billion existing and €45 billion proposed loans to Ukraine as being a “very rough back-of-the-envelope calculation”.
The first guarantee has already been passed by the Oireachtas, and surely to have done that our legislators must have insisted on knowing the amount we would have to pay. I understand that the additional funding for next year is expected to be finalised shortly, so this figure, too, must be quite precisely known.
Almost more disturbing than the apparent uncertainty about the amount is the fact that we do not appear to have accounted for this in the Budget.
In theory Ukraine will repay the loans from the reparations that it receives from Russia at the end of the war, with the €135 billion total adequately covered by the €200 billion in Russian state assets that the EU has frozen to provide immediate funding for the reparations that Russia agrees to pay.
RM Block
However, no one could seriously expect such reparations to be paid. It is the victor that requires reparations from the loser and, while we may legitimately hope that Ukraine doesn’t suffer a complete defeat, it has been clear for years that it can’t possibly win.
Even if by some miracle Ukraine at the end of the war were in a position to demand reparations from Russia, then, as Power points out, it might trade reparations for “some important concession from Moscow elsewhere” – which Kyiv would be virtually certain to do since the concession would benefit them and the money forgone would have been coming to us.
I should like to have a clearer idea both of the range of the amount to which we are exposed and the means of financing the payment that is virtually certain to be demanded from us. – Yours, etc,
WILLIAM HUNT,
Northbrook Avenue,
Ranelagh,
Dublin 6.












