Subscriber OnlyHealth

GP access to MRI scans in community for those over 60 with hip, knee issues to end

HSE says move largely based on clinical evidence and follows audit earlier this year

The HSE is discontinuing hip and knee MRI scans under the GP access scheme for patients over 60. Photograph: Getty Images/iStockphoto
The HSE is discontinuing hip and knee MRI scans under the GP access scheme for patients over 60. Photograph: Getty Images/iStockphoto

Patients aged over 60 will no longer be able to receive MRI scans for hip and knee issues under a scheme that allowed GPs to facilitate community access to such diagnostics.

The HSE said the arrangement was ending following an audit earlier this year, with the changes to the scheme based largely on clinical evidence.

However, an internal HSE financial report, dated October 30th, said it was working to estimate the savings to be generated from discontinuing hip and knee MRI scans under the GP access scheme. It said there were about 21,000 scans provided each year.

The scheme aims to alleviate pressure on hospitals by enabling earlier access to diagnostics in the community.

The HSE said the move aimed “to align clinical practice with evidence-based guidance and to support the appropriate use of radiology resources”.

It said this followed “a review of referral activity, clinical evidence and international best-practice guidelines” as well as engagement with the national clinical programme for trauma and orthopaedic surgery and others.

“It was recognised that MRI is not routinely indicated in the assessment of osteoarthritis of the hip and knee in older adults,” the HSE said.

It said osteoarthritis occurs more frequently with increasing age and is particularly common in people aged 50 and older.

“For most patients in this age group, diagnosis can be made through clinical assessment and, where required, plain X-ray imaging. This change does not prevent patients from accessing MRI where clinically indicated,” the HSE said.

[ HSE crisis: leaked recordings, recriminations and a major political rowOpens in new window ]

“Patients presenting with concerning symptoms, atypical features or suspected alternative diagnoses can continue to be referred through appropriate specialist pathways, where further imaging, including MRI, may be requested as part of specialist assessment and management.”

The HSE said “the efficient use of finite MRI capacity is an important consideration”, but that the change was based on “clinical evidence regarding the most appropriate diagnostic pathway for this patient group”.

The community diagnostics scheme delivers 240,000 scans annually across the health regions.

Prof Tadhg Crowley, chairman of the Irish Medical Organisation’s GP committee, said the move would place pressure on doctors to inform patients the service was no longer available and then refer them to what was likely to be a long waiting list in a hospital setting.

“We would encourage the HSE to prepare communication material for patients in this regard and not place the onus on GPs,” he said.

Labour Party health spokeswoman Marie Sherlock said the move was regressive and created an inequality issue for older people.

[ Steep rise in flu cases and hospitalisations amid vaccine shortageOpens in new window ]

“This is a really blunt cut which is going to particularly hurt those who don’t have health insurance, can’t gain speedy access to a diagnostic image to rule in or out a particular injury or issue, and who will have to face into lengthy waiting lists of 18 months or more just to get a diagnostic before they are seen by a consultant,” she said.

“It’s clear the main reason for the cut is that the HSE depends largely on private diagnostic imaging providers for this really good scheme and are now having to apply cutbacks.”

She said third-party medical imagining diagnostics were running at “21 per cent over budget” by the end of September. “While the clinical indication for hip MRIs is low, we know that MRIs are really important for knee injuries and other degenerative wear and tear.”

Martin Wall

Martin Wall

Martin Wall is the Public Policy Correspondent of The Irish Times.