What is the row over the UK’s nearly 200-year-old consulate in Jerusalem?

UK’s diplomatic mission will operate on a smaller scale after Israel ordered it shut over a sanctions row

Staff leave the British consulate general building in East Jerusalem on Thursday. Photograph: Abir Sultan/EPA
Staff leave the British consulate general building in East Jerusalem on Thursday. Photograph: Abir Sultan/EPA

The UK said on Thursday its nearly 200-year-old consulate in Jerusalem would continue operating on a smaller scale ‌and be renamed as the UK Mission in the city, after Israel ordered it shut in a dispute over sanctions on settlements.

Here’s what to know about the dispute ‌and diplomatic missions in the Holy City.

Why is this happening?

The dispute is over sanctions. Israel’s order for the consulate to shut was retaliation for ​the UK government saying it would impose a ban on the trade of goods made in Israeli settlements.

On September 8th, Israel ordered the UK to close the East Jerusalem consulate within 30 days and remove its diplomats from the city. The deadline expired on Thursday, with the UK and Israel announcing a compromise that would keep the facility open.

Why is the consulate in Jerusalem and where is the embassy?

The consulate is located in the Sheikh Jarrah neighbourhood of East Jerusalem and handles the UK’s relations with Palestinians ⁠in the city as well as in the occupied West Bank and in the Gaza Strip. It also provides consular ‌services ‌to Palestinians.

The ​consulate has been in Jerusalem since about 1839, according to the National Library of Israel, when the area was part of the Ottoman Empire and long before Israel’s establishment in 1948.

East Jerusalem is ⁠considered occupied territory under international law.

The UK’s embassy in Israel, ​like most countries’, is in Tel Aviv, which is also home to ​some government departments. The Israeli prime minister’s office, presidency and parliament are in Jerusalem.

Why is Jerusalem’s situation so complicated?

Jerusalem has long had a ‌bitterly contested status.

It was under British control under ​the Mandate for Palestine. That ended around the time of Israel’s creation in 1948.

Under a United Nations resolution, Jerusalem was meant ⁠to come under international governance due to its special status ⁠in Judaism, Christianity and Islam.

In ​the event, Arab countries attacked Israel after its establishment, and the 1948 Arab-Israeli war resulted in Israeli control of West Jerusalem and Jordanian control of East Jerusalem, including most of the city’s holy sites.

Israel captured East Jerusalem in the 1967 Six-Day War and annexed it in 1980, coming to control the entire city.

Israel considers the whole of Jerusalem as its capital, but most countries do not recognise that claim and consider East Jerusalem occupied by Israel.

Palestinians want East Jerusalem as the capital of a future state. Decades of negotiations have failed to determine a final status.

Which other countries have the British consular arrangement?

Turkey and several western ⁠countries including France, Belgium, Greece, Italy, Spain and Sweden.

Has Israel closed any of their consulates?

No. France joined the UK in announcing sanctions, along with Canada, which does not have a consulate in Jerusalem. Israel has not taken action against ‌Paris.

What about the United States, Israel’s closest ally?

The United States moved its embassy from Tel Aviv and merged it with its consulate in Jerusalem during US president ​Donald Trump’s first term in 2018, the first US administration to make the move.

The US ​was meant to have moved it by 1999 under a Congressional law, but successive presidents postponed the move on national security grounds, in efforts to avoid scuttling chances for peace between Israel and the Palestinians. – Reuters

[ The Middle East in mapsOpens in new window ]

[ What is the Nakba?Opens in new window ]

[ The origins of Israel's conflicts with Iran, Hamas and HizbullahOpens in new window ]

  • Understand world events with Denis Staunton's Global Briefing newsletter

  • Join The Irish Times on WhatsApp and stay up to date

  • Listen to In The News podcast daily for a deep dive on the stories that matter