A sales executive at a human resources firm who claimed her male colleagues were being given more and better leads on new business has lost her gender discrimination case.
The Workplace Relations Commission (WRC) has rejected a series of complaints by Amanda Ball, a Dublin-based sales executive, in a set of decisions published on Friday.
Legal filings on behalf of Ball in 2023 stated that her annual earnings were “drastically reduced” when the company, Peninsula Business Services (Ireland), brought in a new system for assigning sales leads in 2020.
Ball’s annual earnings averaged €145,300 from 2015 to 2020, but dropped from €128,500 in 2020 to €59,000 in 2021, it was alleged.
RM Block
She blamed this on the firm giving “preferential treatment” to men under a new system for assigning sales leads.
[ Budget Q&A: Submit your questions to our expert panel on budget dayOpens in new window ]
However, the company said the assignment of sales leads was tied not to the gender, but to the rate at which members of the sales team were converting these to new business.
Giving evidence, Raj Singh, the chief executive of Peninsula’s Irish arm, told the WRC that the cost to the firm of generating sales leads was “substantial” – referring in particular to its online advertising.
“Leads must therefore be directed to those most likely to convert them,” he said.
Records from Peninsula’s lead allocation system were produced to adjudication officer Brian Dalton.
Ireland’s economic outlook ahead of Budget 2027 and agentic AI going rogue
He said there had been a reduction in the number of “office-generated” sales leads assigned to Ball, giving rise to an inference of discrimination that fell to the employer to rebut.
“The records show that the complainant’s conversion rate was below the team average in most months of 2022, and below that of the male comparator she identified in every month recorded,” Dalton said.
Dalton also said a female comparator earned “substantially more” in 2022 than Ball, while some male comparators “earned substantially less”.
“The variation in earnings between individuals of the same sex was considerably greater than any variation between the sexes,” he said in his decision.
“I am satisfied that the difference in the allocation of leads and appointments and the consequent difference in earnings was determined by conversion performance, and not by sex.
“The same system applied to male and female business development managers alike, and its operation produced no pattern along gender lines.”
He said Ball was not “treated less favourably because she is a woman” in relation to the pay matter.
In a further complaint, Ball alleged she suffered less favourable treatment, either for making a discrimination claim or making a bullying complaint or both.
On October 14th, 2022, Peninsula held what its legal team said was a “major conference” in Ireland and which was mandatory for all sales staff.
Ball and a male colleague declined to attend the full event, and both were later subject to disciplinary hearings in relation to the matter, it was submitted. No sanction arose from the disciplinary process, Peninsula’s lawyers said.
In a complaint to the WRC, Ball said Singh called her “disrespectful and selfish” for indicating she would not stay for dinner and drinks after the conference.
She described being approached by Singh in front of other colleagues at the event and told she was to “rethink her decision” not to stay.
Ball said this caused her “distress and humiliation”.
Singh denied calling Ball “disrespectful and selfish”. He said his remark was that “deliberately not recognising the efforts and achievements of colleagues would be selfish and disrespectful to those colleagues”.
It was the firm’s position that both staff were treated “in the same way” and that what happened in relation to the conference had “nothing to do with any complaint she had made or any threat of legal proceedings”.
