Trial date set for Quinn family’s case against IBRC

Relatives of bankrupt businessman deny liability for €2.34bn in Anglo loans

The Commercial Court action by Patricia Quinn and her five children denying liability for loans from the former Anglo Irish Bank had been suspended  pending the hearing of criminal proceedings against three former Anglo executives. Photograph: Collins
The Commercial Court action by Patricia Quinn and her five children denying liability for loans from the former Anglo Irish Bank had been suspended pending the hearing of criminal proceedings against three former Anglo executives. Photograph: Collins

The Director of Public Prosecutions has cleared the way for the full hearing next year of the action by bankrupt businessman Sean Quinn's family denying liability for some €2.34 billion loans advanced by the former Anglo Irish Bank to Quinn companies.

At the request of the DPP, the Commercial Court action by Patricia Quinn and her five children had been parked pending the hearing of criminal proceedings against three former Anglo executives.

Following the conclusion of the criminal case last month, and the DPP's consent to the stay being lifted, Mr Justice Peter Kelly today directed the Quinns' case could begin on April 13th 2015. He was told it could run for between four to eight months.

The case is against IBRC and its special liquidator Kieran Wallace.   IBRC previously secured orders joining Sean Quinn and two former senior Quinn Group executives, Dara O'Reilly and Liam McCaffrey as notice parties.

READ SOME MORE

Martin Hayden SC, for the family, also said today his side intends to appply shortly to have the Commercial Court fast-track their separate action brought against the Central Bank, in its capacity as financial regulator, Department of Finance, and several former Anglo Irish Bank executives over the making of the loans.

The Quinns filed that action last year after studying some 250 hours of transcripts of phone conversations dating from 2007 between Anglo, the Department and Central Bank concerning matters arising from Sean Quinn’s building up a stake in the bank to 29.4 per cent.

The family’s main action against IBRC was initiated in May 2011 and the Commercial Court has dealt with dozens of pre-trial applications since.

Today, Mr Justice Kelly was told the DPP was not objecting to the lifting of the stay on those proceedings. Paul Anthony McDermott Bl, for the DPP, said the Director did not consider it would impact on any outstanding matters in the criminal proceedings.

In those circumstances, the judge approved a timetable for discovery and exchange of legal documents which has been agreed between the sides prior to the hearing on April 13th next. The ultimate costs of the marathon litigation expected to be tens of millions of Euro.

In their proceedings, the Quinns deny liability for some €2.3 billion of total loans of about €2.8 billion which they claim were given illegally by the bank to prop up its share price.

The bank’s own action alleging a conspiracy by the Quinn defendants and others to strip assets valued at up to €455 million in the Quinn’s international property group was initiated in June 2011 but was also stayed at the request of the DPP due to the criminal proceedings involving the former Anglo executives.

The legal costs of that case to date are conservatively estimated at well over €15 million.

The Quinns claim loans of about €54 million were made to IPG companies of which, they allege, only €9.2 million relates to companies involved in the conspiracy case. They claim the rest of the €445 million sum is not relevent to the conspiracy case.

A full hearing date for the conspiracy action has yet to be set but there have been more than 40 pre-trial applications, including for orders freezing accounts of several family members and contempt proceedings resulting in the jailing of Sean Quinn and his son Sean Junior.

The case has also involved applications in other courts worldwide, including Russia and Cyprus.

Mary Carolan

Mary Carolan

Mary Carolan is the Legal Affairs Correspondent of the Irish Times