We all know how important it is to read and understand the T&Cs attached to the various services we use, but many people don’t do either of these things with any great rigour. That is entirely understandable.
Terms and conditions can be dense and boring, and it can be hard to keep on top of every single thing we have going on.
The consequences of letting things slide, however, can be dire – as two recent stories from readers illustrate. Both have Eir at their core.
A reader called Gerard got in touch in relation to the Eir account belonging to his 84-year-old father.
RM Block
“A few weeks ago, I discovered that my father was paying €102 per month for his Eir broadband,” Gerard writes.
It sounded like a lot, he says, and, with a view to investigating further, he set himself up as an authorised user. “When I contacted Eir, I learned that he had been out of contract for more than 10 years so had been moved to a standard out-of-contract plan whose price had increased over time,” he says.
“With one phone call, I was able to move him on to a new contract costing €35 per month – a saving of €804 a year.
“What concerns me is how this situation was allowed to continue for so long. Eir also held an incorrect email address for my father, raising questions about whether he received the relevant end-of-contract notices, information about cheaper tariffs, and other important communications,” he says.
He lodged a formal complaint with Eir asking it to investigate what notifications were issued, whether the incorrect email address affected those communications and whether any historic charges or failures warrant a refund or other financial redress.
[ The death of customer service: Eir is not alone in letting its customers downOpens in new window ]
He says that the “difference between what my father paid and the cheaper rate could amount to thousands of euro over the years, although I appreciate that this is not necessarily the same as money legally owed to him”.
He accepts that Eir “may argue that its standard out-of-contract rates were valid. However, I think there is a wider consumer question about how long-standing customers, particularly older people, can remain on expensive plans for years while much cheaper deals are available.”
Next up is Paulo’s story.
He says he was “a long-standing Eir customer, and recently switched broadband provider after unsuccessfully attempting to renegotiate my monthly costs”.
One of the reasons he had been so anxious to cut the cost of his Eir account was because “at the time I was unemployed, and trying to reduce household expenses”.
He left Eir having found a cheaper deal elsewhere, but there was a real sting in the tale.
“After switching, I received a final bill which included an early cease charge of €1,251.88,” he says.
He got in touch with the company and was given a breakdown of the charges. He was being asked to pay a daily rate of €2.66 for each of the 470 or so days that were left on his contract.
“My concern is not that an early termination charge exists, but that the charge appears to be based on the full undiscounted service price, and results in a bill that feels disproportionate to the circumstances,” he writes.
He raised a formal complaint with Eir and contacted ComReg, but says the provider “maintains that the charge is valid under the contract terms”.
“I’m wondering whether this is an issue you have encountered before and whether there may be broader consumer awareness concerns around the potential cost of switching telecom providers while under contract.”
As we said at the start, T&Cs do matter, but charging a man in his 80s more than €100 a month for broadband when there are much cheaper deals on the market and hitting a person who is unemployed with a charge of more than €1,200 because they want to exit a contract to save money does seem a little harsh.
We sent both stories to Eir more in hope than in expectation.
This is what it said in response.
“Eir has reviewed both cases and considered the circumstances of each account. We are committed to ensuring that customers receive services suited to their needs. In the first case, the email address held on the account was incorrect, although our records show that Eir contacted the customer by post. We encourage customers to keep their contact details up to date, so they receive important information about their accounts and services. We have since reviewed the account and confirmed that the customer is on the best available offer.
“In the second case, the customer recontracted in January and spoke with Eir in June, when his contract terms through to January 2028 were discussed. The customer moved to another provider in October without contacting Eir again.”
















